I got some interesting questions in the comments of the How To Choose A Domain Name For Your Niche Website lesson, here’s one of them:
So a yourkeyword.net is always preferred over a your-keyword.com?
Do most people feel .net is more acceptable than dashes?
The question is basically whether it’s a good idea to use dashes in domains that you buy.
I personally have some domains with dashes and I’ve seen a few drawbacks. I’m not totally against them, but to be honest, with the drawbacks that they have I can’t justify going with them when there are better options.
There are two big drawbacks that I see with dashed-domains:
- The resale value is lowered.
- The click-through rate from search engines to your site is lower. No one would be able to test this without having two sites that rank for the same keyword – fortunately I have seen this situation and can tell you that the dashes seem to affect this. It isn’t going to affect it by a huge amount but dashed domains do tend to look a little more spammy than domains that aren’t dashed and this will make a small amount of people skip over them.
The question asked more specifically if you should choose ‘yourkeyword.net’ over ‘your-keyword.com’ and this is a definite yes. With yourkeyword.net you have an exact keyword match in the domain and this will give you a ranking advantage. I don’t have any evidence personally that ‘your-keyword.com’ gives you the exact match bonus with Google, in fact my experience tells me that it seems not to.
I don’t really know (or care to be honest) what most people prefer. All I know is what my results have told me and that’s what I trust.
